Where Flavor Meets Affordability: Cartagena’s Culinary Hidden Gems
Cartagena’s lively streets are a feast for the senses, where history, culture, and gastronomy intertwine. While the city boasts its share of upscale restaurants, it’s the affordable and trendy restaurants in Cartagena—especially in the Old City and Getsemaní—that truly capture the spirit of the city. These places offer more than just delicious meals—they provide an experience that’s rich in local flavor and style.
La Mulata: Affordable and Trendy Caribbean Comfort Food in Cartagena
📍 Calle Cochera del Hobo #38-26
Why You’ll Love It: Stepping into La Mulata feels like being embraced by Cartagena itself. Known for its eclectic decor and warm atmosphere, this spot serves quintessential Caribbean comfort food. Think coconut rice, fried plantains, and succulent fish fillets bursting with flavor. The daily lunch specials are a steal, offering a starter, main course, dessert, and juice—all for a price that’s kind to your wallet. Don’t forget to snap a photo of the quirky murals while you wait!
2. TacoBeach: Where Tacos Meet the Tropics
📍 Calle Santo Domingo #3-96
Why You’ll Love It: If you think Mexican food in Cartagena might be an odd pairing, TacoBeach will prove you wrong. This casual spot infuses tacos, burritos, and quesadillas with a Caribbean twist. Their shrimp tacos are a crowd favorite, and the laid-back beach vibe makes it the perfect stop after a day of sightseeing. Bonus points for their margaritas—they pack a punch without packing on the price.
If you’re looking for affordable and trendy restaurants in Cartagena that offer Mexican-inspired dishes with a Caribbean twist, TacoBeach is a must-visit for a quick bite on the go. Technically, it is not a restaurant but rather a ‘shack’ in the centre of the Old City. You might even be tempted to have a quick sneaky cerveza or tequilla midday!
3. Pezetarian: Fresh, Healthy, and Delicious
📍 Calle Segunda de Badillo #36-19
Why You’ll Love It: Sushi rolls, poke bowls, and vibrant salads define this chic eatery’s menu. Pezetarian caters to the health-conscious crowd while keeping prices incredibly reasonable. It’s the perfect spot for a light yet satisfying meal that doesn’t leave you feeling guilty. The minimalist decor and thoughtful plating make it an Instagram-worthy stop.
4. El Pescadito Cevicheria: Affordable Fresh Ceviche in Cartagena
📍 Calle Cochera del Hobo #38-26
Why You’ll Love It: This is the place to go for fresh, tangy ceviche served up in a casual, unpretentious setting. Locals rave about their mixed seafood ceviche, packed with shrimp, octopus, and fish marinated to perfection. Wash it down with a chilled local beer while people-watching from their outdoor seating area.
5. Café Stepping Stone: Socially Conscious & Seriously Tasty
📍 Calle Espiritu Santo #29-176
Why You’ll Love It: Here’s a spot where every bite does good. Café Stepping Stone is a social enterprise supporting underprivileged youth, but the food is the real star. Their brunch offerings—like smashed avocado toast or fluffy arepas—are fresh, flavorful, and filling. Pair it with their ethically sourced coffee, and you’ve got a meal that’s as uplifting as its mission. This gem is another example of affordable and trendy restaurants in Cartagena that pair flavorful meals with social impact.
6. La Cocina de Pepina: Tradition with a Twist
📍 Callejon Ancho 9A-06
Why You’ll Love It: This intimate spot in Getsemaní is where Colombian heritage shines. The decor is colorful and homely, perfectly matching their soulful dishes. Order the posta negra, a rich beef dish slow-cooked in a dark, sweet sauce, or their mote de queso, a cheesy soup that’s pure comfort. The portions are generous, and the prices feel like a throwback to simpler times.
7. El Bistro: European Charm Meets Local Flair
📍 Calle de Ayos #4-46
Why You’ll Love It: Run by a German chef, El Bistro brings a slice of Europe to Cartagena’s Old Town. You’ll find dishes like schnitzels, fresh pasta, and hearty salads, all crafted with love. Despite its European flair, the restaurant remains surprisingly affordable, with lunch specials that locals swear by. Its cozy atmosphere makes it ideal for a quiet, intimate meal.
8. La Cevicheria: Seafood Royalty at Fair Prices
📍 Calle Stuart 7-14
Why You’ll Love It: Made famous by Anthony Bourdain, La Cevicheria lives up to its hype without the hefty price tag. While you may wait for a table, it’s worth it for the impeccably fresh ceviches and the breezy, alfresco dining experience. Pro tip: Order their house special ceviche and pair it with a mojito for the ultimate Cartagena treat.
Experience Cartagena Through Affordable and Trendy Dining
Dining in Cartagena doesn’t have to mean splurging. From laid-back taco joints to social enterprises and iconic seafood spots, these restaurants prove that affordable doesn’t have to mean ordinary. Each offers something unique, whether it’s traditional Colombian recipes, modern health-conscious options, or global cuisine with a local twist. The best part? They all let you savor the heart and soul of Cartagena without breaking the bank. Dining at these affordable and trendy restaurants in Cartagena ensures you experience the city’s vibrant culture without stretching your budget
Martha Hampton
Home Curator
Founder of Cartagena Colombia Rentals & Hampton Property Rentals Inc
